In this post, I will seek to answer the question of how many injuries Duke can have to its best players while remaining a top 10 team this season.
Kenpom projects Syracuse to be the #12 team this season. Xavier is #11, but comparing Duke's stats and talent level to Xavier's seems much less useful than comparing Duke's stats and talent level to Syracuse, given that Duke and Syracuse have recently played similar schedules and recruited from roughly similar talent pools. So I'll compare Duke's roster with Syracuse's and see how they stack up as Duke's best remaining player is removed from the roster one by one.
Syracuse's roster, in order of projected value based on a subjective magic formula:
1 PF Tyler Lydon (sophomore, 9.7 BPM last season)
2 C Paschal Chukwu (sophomore transfer, 6.2 BPM last season played on Providence)
3 SF Tyler Roberson (sophomore, 5.8 BPM last season)
4 SG Andrew White (senior grad transfer, 5.7 BPM last season on Nebraska)
5 C DaJuan Coleman (senior, 5.3 BPM last season)
6 SG Tyus Battle (freshman, composite #36 recruit)
7 SF Matthew Moyer (freshman, composite #67 recruit)
8 PF Taurean Thompson (freshman, composite #74 recruit)
9 PG John Gillon (senior grad transfer, 2.2 BPM last season on Colorado State)
10 PG Franklin Howard (sophomore, -1.2 BPM last season)
Duke's roster:
1 Amile Jefferson (10.3 BPM last season in limited minutes)
2 Grayson Allen (9.7 BPM last season)
3 Harry Giles (composite #2 recruit)
4 Jayson Tatum (composite #4 recruit)
5 Luke Kennard (6.3 BPM last season)
6 Matt Jones (6.0 BPM last season)
7 Frank Jackson (composite #13 recruit)
8 Marques Bolden (composite #15 recruit)
9 Javin DeLaurier (composite #39 recruit)
10 Chase Jeter (0.3 BPM last season)
11 Antonio Vrankovic (-2.2 BPM last season in limited minutes)
12 Sean Obi (-3.3 BPM last season in limited minutes)
13 Jack White (composite #226 recruit)
Looking at the basic BPM and recruiting numbers, is Duke better than Syracuse on paper if we remove Jefferson? Probably.
If we remove Jefferson and Allen? Probably.
If we remove Jefferson and Allen and Giles? Starts to get dicey.
I would say Duke would be in or around the top 10 this season if Duke were to lose its three most valuable players to injury. That's reassuring, because Duke will lose several players to injury this season.